[BLAUGRANA]

I too voted “yes” and am happy with the changes to the process. Adding two U21 players isn’t a lot and I doubt we notice any big changes.

Zizou, enjoy Wyoming!

[BLAUGRANA]

One more point about the additional 70 players. That’s just this window and assuming everyone adds five new players.

More importantly, welcome Ramer and Zooka!

[BLAUGRANA]

james wrote:

evilo wrote:

So the whole point is that rich get richer?

the point is to be fiscally responsible with your club.

See, now I interpret this as “don’t do business with James and his inflated transfer valuations.” 😉

Kawai wrote:

All excellent points made

Q for Z – if we change our votes to no could we then amend the proposal to a more simplified and incremental expansion say 2 additional players instead the academy and 5? that would reduce our feeling sus about the market changes and gives us a little more room to experiment with? Would that have more support?

I think this is kind of what I was saying, but with just fewer players. Again, I think simplification is better.

[BLAUGRANA]

Full disclosure, but I voted yes.

I’m all for the rule changes that Zizou has made and I think he has demonstrated some sensible deliberation. I have two things about the U21/Academy piece:

-I don’t think the addition of players based on what Zizou has put forward is a lot. What I know I was looking for and probably others as I understand would have added notably more players. However, as I said, I think Zizou has deliberated and made a sensible proposal that makes incremental change at a rate that won’t explode or dilute the market and will allow for further reflection in a year.

-I do think the process change with regards to the U21 sides and Academy players is a bit convoluted. I would say just increase the U21 roster size, give everyone 2.5 million and use the current rule regarding players not in FM (change the number allowed if you so choose). You could also eliminate the stipulation as to which window any U21 players are picked up in and if you want you can say players not in FM can’t be traded until they are in FM. I just think the process and rules will be simplified as a result.

9690 wrote:

One can argue the league has never been more competitive than it is right now with the current rules in place.

Are you saying this because James won?

9690 wrote:

You can scroll up and see who’s opposed.

I know you’ve alluded to JR’s High School days before and I assumed he was just reliving those days with the group.

9691 wrote:

And again I don’t have a problem with people against it. But 4 blocking 8 seems harsh is all I’m saying.

I agree with this. Were this more something larger in scope such that it would greatly impact the league I would say something more than a simple majority would make more sense.

[BLAUGRANA]

I voted, but I am requesting you disclose the manufacturer of the voting machines you’re using. I’d also like to be present when votes are tabulated. Oh, and I changed my email today so if you one from the below emails it’s from me:

ahhyeahobviimgoingtobethenextdynastyligawinner@gmail.com

[BLAUGRANA]

Roberdino, my favorite nickname on here! Sad to see you go sir as I felt you were building well for the future. Hopefully you come back some day.

[BLAUGRANA]

evilo wrote:

Btw Z, I’ll once again ask to consider expanding U21 rosters. I know a few GMs agree and I’m sure some don’t, which is fine.
But I feel like :
1/ it rewards GM who follow leagues everywhere instead of EPL only.
2/ it can be a great way to take a poor team and make it progress because you’re taking small bids on young players without much hype.

The current system penalises GMs who are good at detecting young talents.
That’s how I see it, and others can fully see it the other way around.

If we’re having this discussion I am all for expanding U21 rosters. I’ve made my feelings known to Zizou which would allow for notable expansion, but it would have parameters and it would NOT mean added fixtures to be simmed. Generally speaking though I all for U21 expansion.

[BLAUGRANA]

Luigi wrote:

Unfortunately I will have to step out.

I must admit I haven’t been a good owner the past 2 years. I have prepared my list for free agency but my life with 3 young kids + very demanding job + coaching is not allowing me put the necessary effort to enjoy this great league. It saddens me because there are so many kids I picked up which I’m excited to see how they grow for me.

I may come back in a few years. It’s been a blast for me since I joined. Thanks for everyone making this league what it is. The quality of owners have increased year after year.

Good luck everyone. Maybe now Evilo might be able to get Cherki

Yeah, you definitely have some guys I’m curious to see going forward. That said I can understand how life gets in the way. Hopefully you come back some day because it’s nice to have competitive GMs. Best of luck to you!

[BLAUGRANA]

FFS, the season just ended.

[BLAUGRANA]

Phew. I was sweating this one whilst waiting for the result. Need every dollar! Happy to see Aspas cap off a strong season after losing his place early on. Also nice to get more from Olmo. GG Luigi and thanks for simming Zizou!

[BLAUGRANA]

Wow, back to back? Congratulations.

[BLAUGRANA]

At least I went out against the eventual winner, LOL. Congrats on Gooner! Amazing Double.

[BLAUGRANA]

Congrats James! What a season.

[BLAUGRANA]

Wow. Well not the result I expected so I’ll take it. Love seeing Alvarez on the scoresheet again. Once again GG ProPain and thanks for simming James.

[BLAUGRANA]

Couldn’t have asked for anything more from this fixture. Exactly what I wanted and needed. So glad I went with Haaland this season. Nice to see the assist from Alba too considering he was injured pretty much the entire back half of the season.

GG ProPain and thanks for simming James.

• This reply was modified 3 years, 1 month ago by BLAUGRANA.

[Author]

Posts